Skip to the main content

* Required
* Required
;

Outsourcing vs. Internal Product Development

TAKING A NEW PRODUCT TO MARKET

Taking a New Product to Market

Outsourcing vs. Internal Product Development

Download eBook

Developing and taking new products to market is critical to the success of your brand, but studies show that 95% of newly developed products fail in market. This can occur for a variety of reasons, including poor design, failed marketing initiatives, or poor choice in manufacturing or distribution partners.

While many companies have resources in-house to facilitate new product development (NPD), many organizations have begun to outsource the NPD process. This eBook will help you make an informed decision when choosing if outsourcing NPD is right for you.

A successful on-time, on-budget launch of your project relates to the availability of resources within your organization. Analysis of these resources can help determine whether outsourcing NPD is the right solution. When determining whether to outsource, consider the following:

• The opportunity cost of internal NPD versus outsourcing: What is your organization foregoing to accomplish this project? Will outsourcing allow your organization to take on more projects or improve speed to market if you balance projects with external resources? 

• An examination of the common pitfalls of internal NPD: Do office politics or resource competition interfere with good business opportunities? 

• An evaluation of the core competencies of your organization in relation to NPD: Do you have the engineering resources and/or the manufacturing knowledge to understand the obstacles of taking a project from design to production? 

• Ability to staff all the needed internal engineering resources: In today’s tight job market, qualified, experienced engineers are difficult to find and retain. 

Careful consideration of the pitfalls and resources within your organization will assist the decision on whether outsourcing NPD will be a more efficient, more cost-effective option.

Pitfalls of In-House NPD

If all the resources for product launch are in place within your organization, then a successful NPD can be successful. However, your company can run into a number of hurdles that will hinder successful development if those resources are lacking or completely unavailable. The common pitfalls of internal NPD include:

Design-to-Manufacturer Hand-Off Issues

Your design team can create a fantastic concept but may not understand the feasibility of manufacturing the product. Miscommunications of this sort between design engineers and manufacturing can cause production issues and product launch delays. This means you’ll not only need designers on staff, but manufacturing engineers that understand the capabilities and limitations of manufacturing processes. 

Design for Manufacturability (DFM) is an important milestone in the the NPD process. Successful DFM requires an ability for designers and manufacturers to collaborate during the development process, but many organizations experience a critical disconnect between ideation and fabrication. Outsourcing development to a specialist ensures that the design will incorporate manufacturability from its early stages. Not all NPD designers can handle the handoff to production directly. Look for an NPD partner that can offer a full end-to-end service, from design to manufacturing, to minimize collaboration problems.

Internal Production Costs Challenges

There are several areas where production costs may become challenging. In some instances, organizations acquire resources they might not need or may only need short-term. Conversely, organizations may lack an overall understanding of the specifics of manufacturing and incorrectly allocate limited resources. 

A correct understanding of the scope of development, design, and production can help to mitigate problems with cost or resource allocation. Areas to consider include:

• Materials 
• Sizes 
• Tolerances/Stack up 
• Manufacturability 
• Manufacturing processes 
• Tooling 
• Material costs (some manufacturers can offer lower material rates due to bulk purchases) 

Outsourcing can offset many of these costs. An NPD partner will understand the production costs associated with the design and development process and incorporate those costs into their estimate. This offers an unbiased view of the overarching cost of NPD early on.

Limited Resources

Handling NPD in-house ultimately strains the resources of the research and development team and slows the organization’s ability to release new products. An internal R&D team has limited capacity to work on new product development for multiple products. This can often cause bottlenecks across the organization for NPD. 

Outsourcing greatly expands access to resources for NPD. A quality NPD partner will have the capacity and experience to work on several projects concurrently, which will support an expansion of your company’s product footprint.

Sticking to Core Competencies in NPD

Successful NPD requires an intricate understanding of the design and production process for your particular product. If your new product requires a different material or a manufacturing capability outside of your existing expertise, this may be the time to look for external resources and support. For this reason, many OEMs stick to their core competencies and outsource elements that are beyond what they know and understand. When a third party assists with NPD, it helps decrease time to market and overall costs by eliminating the need for:

• New equipment purchases 
• Hiring in-house engineers 
• Project management 
• Additional personnel training 
• Prototyping capabilities 
• Testing  

Another aspect of improving time to market and reducing costs relates to expertise and experience in both the design and manufacturing phases of NPD. Outsourcing elements of your product launch which are beyond your core competences allows those with expertise to provide the solutions you need.

NPD Engineering Resources

A major component in new product development relates to engineering the new product. Though retaining a team of in-house design engineers may seem like the ideal solution, the reality of hiring and maintaining them is a constant struggle. Data from the Smithsonian shows a shortage of qualified STEM workers in the industrial sector that will exceed 2.4 million by 2028. Simply put—it’s hard to hire experienced engineers and they don’t come cheap. 

Several factors work against retaining in-house design engineers, such as: 

• High demand for design engineers 
• Labor shortage of design engineers 
• Costs associated with training and paying in-house engineers force your organization to hire inexperienced engineers

Outsourcing to a firm with an established team of engineers already on-staff helps your project benefit from a higher level of experience and expertise. This is especially important when working with complex components or designs. Understanding the feasibility of manufacturing your product ensures that all cost saving opportunities will be identified throughout the process.

Choosing the Right NPD Supplier and Partner

NPD outsourcing is becoming very commonplace. The Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) market is expected to exceed $343 billion by 2025, according to data from Grand View Research. However, it’s critical that you choose the right supplier/partner.

 Trusting NPD to a contracted supplier can be uncomfortable, and making the right selection will impact your product launch. When choosing the right supplier and partner, your organization should establish a set of standards for hiring contract manufacturers. Those standards should include: 

• Expertise/experience in the sector or sectors where your product will be marketed 

• Flexibility and redundancy in manufacturing capabilities 

• Ability to provide cost reduction to your organization without compromising product quality 

• Capable of seamless transfers in all phases of product design, prototyping, and manufacturing 

• Resources and capabilities to produce your product in the required volumes and lead times

The right outsourced partner in NPD will make a big difference when it comes to a successful launch. Many times, the immediate thought is that outsourcing means working with overseas providers. This can bring on a whole new set of challenges. To mitigate these additional obstacles, consider working with a U.S.-based manufacturer. A domestic partner can: 

Eliminate language barriers 

• Provide faster lead times 

• Offer improved response times 

• Expedite logistics 

• Remove hidden costs associated with non-domestic manufacturers 

• Provide higher quality results, especially on complex products or components. 

Finding a supplier and partner with this long list of credentials may seem difficult—but it doesn’t have to be.

Working with Vollrath Manufacturing Services

Vollrath Manufacturing Services (VMS) provides optimal outsourcing solutions for new product development. Our expert team of technical sales, engineers, designers, and manufacturers work as a single unit, creating a custom-fit, end-to-end approach to NPD. This integrated, collaborative approach ensures a seamless experience while keeping costs down. VMS has experience in providing NPD services in a broad range of industries, including: 

• Food service

• Dispensing (food and beverage service)

• Consumer goods (cookware, appliances, containers, sinks)

• Heavy Equipment (agriculture, construction, lawn and garden)

• Energy and gas

• Medical 

At VMS, we focus on building customer loyalty through our expert capabilities and our bandwidth to deliver on our promises through our actions. 

Organizations considering a new product launch have to choose between in-house or contract manufacturing. Companies who may struggle to avoid the various pitfalls of in-house NPD, lack core competencies in the area they are expanding, or desire to eliminate the costs of in-house design engineers should take a serious look into outsourcing their NPD. Over the long term, outsourcing can have a positive impact on production time and expenses. 

Contact us for more information on how Vollrath Manufacturing Services can support the design and manufacturing of your new product.

Download eBook

Work With Us

We provide custom manufacturing and engineering design consulting, standard and made-to-order parts, and custom tool fabrication.